Cancelled Sequels That Almost Got Made
Hollywood loves a good sequel, but not every follow-up makes it to the finish line. Sometimes creative differences get in the way, sometimes the budget becomes too ambitious, and sometimes the studio just gets cold feet after the first film underperforms.
These cancelled sequels represent some of the most tantalizing ‘what ifs’ in movie history, from superhero epics to sci-fi adventures that had everything lined up except the green light. Here is a list of cancelled sequels that were this close to happening.
Spider-Man 4
Sam Raimi’s fourth Spider-Man film with Tobey Maguire was supposed to hit theaters in May 2011, and it had some serious potential. John Malkovich was cast as Vulture, Anne Hathaway was set to play either Black Cat or a character called Vulturess, and Bruce Campbell was finally getting a meaty role as Mysterio.
Raimi went through four different script revisions but ultimately couldn’t get the story to work on his timeline, leading him to tell Sony they should just reboot the franchise instead.
Hellboy 3
Guillermo del Toro spent nearly a decade trying to make his third Hellboy film happen, but the stars never aligned. The proposed budget ballooned to $120 million, which was way more than studios wanted to spend on a franchise that made decent but not blockbuster money.
Del Toro’s busy schedule didn’t help either—he spent two years developing The Hobbit before dropping out, then moved on to Pacific Rim, and by 2017 he finally confirmed that Hellboy 3 was 100% dead.
E.T. II: Nocturnal Fears
Steven Spielberg actually developed a treatment for an E.T. sequel that would have been much darker than the original. The story featured evil aliens who would torture Elliott and his friends before E.T. returned to save them.
Spielberg wisely decided that some magic shouldn’t be messed with and shelved the project, though the treatment eventually leaked online for curious fans to read.
The Amazing Spider-Man 3
Sony had mapped out an entire cinematic universe around Andrew Garfield’s Spider-Man, with multiple sequels and spin-offs planned. When The Amazing Spider-Man 2 underperformed in 2014, those plans evaporated faster than a web in the rain.
Sony eventually struck a deal with Marvel Studios instead, bringing Spider-Man into the MCU and giving us Tom Holland’s version of the character.
Divergent: Ascendant
The final Divergent film was supposed to split the last book into two movies, just like The Hunger Games did. Allegiant bombed so hard at the box office that Lionsgate decided to turn Ascendant into a TV movie instead, and then that idea fizzled out too.
Shailene Woodley nearly quit acting over the experience, and the franchise ended on a cliffhanger that will never be resolved.
District 10
Neill Blomkamp has been talking about a District 9 sequel since before the first film even came out in 2009. He’s written multiple drafts with star Sharlto Copley, and he’s confirmed the project is in development, but he’s also admitted he doesn’t know if he actually wants to make it right now.
After a string of poorly received films like Elysium, Chappie, and Demonic, Blomkamp seems hesitant to return to the one franchise that actually worked for him.
Fantastic Four 2 (2015)
Fox was so confident in their 2015 Fantastic Four reboot that they scheduled a sequel before the first one even hit theaters. That confidence was misplaced—the movie was plagued by production issues, studio interference, and extensive reshoots, resulting in one of the worst-reviewed superhero films ever made.
The planned sequel was immediately cancelled, and eventually Disney’s acquisition of Fox brought the rights back to Marvel.
The Golden Compass: The Subtle Knife
New Line Cinema desperately wanted The Golden Compass to be the next Lord of the Rings, but fans of Philip Pullman’s novels hated how the film stripped out the religious themes that made the books fascinating. The movie disappointed at the North American box office despite costing a fortune to make, so the planned adaptations of The Subtle Knife and The Amber Spyglass never materialized.
HBO eventually picked up the books for a TV series, giving the material a second chance at proper adaptation.
Mrs. Doubtfire 2
Robin Williams was prepared to return as the beloved nanny, and director Chris Columbus confirmed there was a great script ready to go. Williams’ tragic death in 2014 halted any chance of production, and Columbus has firmly stated that the sequel will definitely never happen now.
Some characters are just too tied to their actors to ever be recast.
Godzilla 2 (1998)
Roland Emmerich’s 1998 Godzilla was meant to be the first installment of a planned trilogy. The film’s final scene showed one of Godzilla’s eggs hatching, complete with an ominous roar before cutting to black.
Critics shredded the movie and fans rejected it, so Sony quickly axed any plans for sequels and the franchise eventually got rebooted decades later.
Eragon Sequels
The 2006 adaptation of Christopher Paolini’s beloved fantasy novel was supposed to launch a new franchise to compete with Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter. Instead, it delivered wooden acting and lifeless storytelling that disappointed fans of The Inheritance Cycle books so thoroughly that the planned sequels were cancelled immediately.
Disney is now developing a streaming series based on the books, with Paolini involved as a co-writer this time.
Dredd 2
Karl Urban’s 2012 Dredd was everything fans wanted from a Judge Dredd adaptation—gritty, violent, and faithful to the comics. The film tanked at the box office despite positive reviews, which killed any hope for the planned sequel.
Screenwriter Alex Garland had expressed interest in tackling the ‘Origins’ and ‘Democracy’ story arcs if they got to make a trilogy.
John Carter: Gods of Mars
Disney was so optimistic about John Carter that director Andrew Stanton had already mapped out two sequels before the first film bombed spectacularly. The second installment would have been titled Gods of Mars and would have centered on John Carter and Dejah Thoris’ child while featuring abductions, wild space travel, and secret alien civilizations.
Instead, John Carter became one of the biggest box office disasters in history.
Roger Rabbit 2
Who Framed Roger Rabbit was a massive hit in 1988, so Disney naturally wanted a follow-up. They planned a prequel called Roger Rabbit: The Toon Platoon that would have taken place in 1941, with Roger rescuing Jessica from Nazi-occupied Europe, though the Nazi subplot was later dropped.
After shooting test footage, the project was deemed too expensive and never made it past development.
Green Lantern 2
Warner Bros. was banking on Green Lantern to launch a DC cinematic universe in 2011, but the film’s poor reception killed those dreams instantly. Ryan Reynolds himself has joked about how bad the movie was, and the planned sequel disappeared as quickly as the CGI suit that fans hated.
The character eventually got a second chance in the animated series and is being set up for a reboot in the new DCU.
Alien 5
Neill Blomkamp developed a fascinating Alien sequel that would have brought Sigourney Weaver back and been set after the events of Aliens, essentially ignoring Alien 3 and Resurrection. The concept art looked incredible, showing an older Ripley and the return of Hicks, but Ridley Scott’s ongoing Prometheus plans took priority.
Weaver later said Scott ‘decided to be very possessive’ about the franchise, effectively killing Blomkamp’s version.
The Lone Ranger 2
Disney expected Johnny Depp’s take on Tonto to launch another Pirates of the Caribbean-style franchise. The 2013 film was criticized as racially insensitive and became a massive box office disappointment despite its enormous budget.
Depp defended the movie and suggested critics were unfair, but producer J. Bruckheimer’s optimistic prediction that future reviews would vindicate them has yet to come true.
When Timing Kills Dreams
The cancelled sequels on this list share a common thread—bad timing derailed projects that might have succeeded under different circumstances. Spider-Man 4 couldn’t meet its deadline, Hellboy 3 arrived just before R-rated superhero films became viable hits with Deadpool and Logan, and District 10 keeps getting pushed back as Blomkamp pursues other projects.
Some of these sequels might still happen someday, like District 10 or a potential return to the Raimi Spider-Man universe through the multiverse, but most will remain nothing more than fascinating footnotes in Hollywood history. The concept art, leaked scripts, and what-could-have-been stories serve as reminders that in the film industry, even the best-laid plans can crumble when studios get nervous about opening their wallets.
More from Go2Tutors!
- The Romanov Crown Jewels and Their Tragic Fate
- 13 Historical Mysteries That Science Still Can’t Solve
- Famous Hoaxes That Fooled the World for Years
- 15 Child Stars with Tragic Adult Lives
- 16 Famous Jewelry Pieces in History
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.
