16 Puzzles Historians Still Can’t Solve

By Ace Vincent | Published

Related:
14 Historic Firsts That Could Happen at the 2025 PGA Championship

History books often present the past as a neatly organized timeline of events, discoveries, and achievements. The reality is far messier.

Countless historical mysteries continue to baffle even the most brilliant minds despite decades or centuries of investigation. Some of these puzzles might never be solved.


Here is a list of 16 historical enigmas that continue to perplex experts, challenging our understanding of the past and reminding us how much remains unknown.

Voynich Manuscript

Image Credit: DepositPhotos

This medieval document contains detailed illustrations of strange plants and astronomical diagrams alongside text written in an unknown language that has resisted all attempts at translation. Carbon dating places the manuscript’s creation around the early 15th century, but no one knows who wrote it or what secrets its indecipherable pages contain.

Some of the world’s top code breakers and linguistics experts have tried and failed to crack its mysterious writing system.

Lost Colony of Roanoke

Image Credit: DepositPhotos

In 1590, the entire population of the Roanoke Colony in present-day North Carolina vanished without explanation, leaving behind only the word ‘CROATOAN’ carved into a post. More than 115 men, women, and children simply disappeared from the settlement between visits from supply ships.

Modern archaeological efforts have uncovered tantalizing clues but no definitive explanation for what happened to these early American settlers.

Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.

Antikythera Mechanism

Image Credit: Flickr by Weekend Wayfarers

This ancient Greek device discovered in a shipwreck contains interlocking gears of remarkable precision that shouldn’t have existed until the 14th century, yet it dates to around 100 BCE. The mechanism could predict astronomical positions and eclipses with astonishing accuracy, displaying mechanical knowledge far beyond what historians believed possible for its time.

Its complexity suggests there may have been many similar devices that were lost to history.

Copper Scroll Treasure

Image Credit: Flickr by Elias Rovielo

Among the Dead Sea Scrolls lies a unique copper document listing what appears to be directions to massive hidden treasures worth billions in today’s money. Unlike the other scrolls, this one isn’t religious but instead describes specific locations where gold, silver, and precious artifacts were supposedly buried.

Scholars debate whether the treasure was real, already found, or simply fictional, while the unusual use of copper instead of parchment suggests its creators wanted this information to last indefinitely.

Easter Island Moai Transport

Image Credit: DepositPhotos

The massive stone heads of Easter Island, some weighing up to 82 tons, were somehow moved miles across difficult terrain by a civilization without wheels, cranes, or draft animals. Various theories suggest they were ‘walked’ by rocking them forward, dragged on wooden sleds, or rolled on logs.

The transportation method remains contested among archaeologists despite numerous experiments attempting to recreate the feat using period-appropriate technology.

Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.

Phaistos Disc

Image Credit: Flickr by Dimitris Agelakis

This clay disc from Bronze Age Crete contains mysterious symbols arranged in a spiral pattern unlike any other known writing system from the ancient world. Each symbol was pressed into the clay using specialized stamps, making this potentially the world’s first printed document around 1700 BCE.

The disc’s purpose, meaning, and even whether it represents language remain hotly debated among experts with theories ranging from religious text to ancient board game.

Baghdad Battery

Image Credit: Flickr by Boynton

These simple clay pots containing copper cylinders and iron rods from ancient Mesopotamia could potentially produce small electrical currents when filled with grape juice or vinegar. Dating from around 250 BCE, they predate modern understanding of electricity by over 2,000 years.

Archaeologists remain divided on whether these devices were actually used as batteries or served some entirely different purpose unrelated to electricity.

Nazca Lines

Image Credit: Flickr by Doug McMillen

Massive geoglyphs etched into the Peruvian desert are only fully visible from high above the ground, raising questions about how and why ancient people created them. Some designs stretch nearly 370 feet across and depict animals, plants, and geometric shapes with remarkable precision.

These drawings have remained preserved for 2,000 years due to the region’s stable climate, yet their purpose remains elusive despite theories ranging from astronomical calendars to alien landing strips.

Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.

Linear A Script

Image Credit: Flickr by John Winder

This writing system used by the Minoan civilization of ancient Crete has resisted all attempts at translation despite extensive scholarly efforts. Unlike its successor Linear B, which was deciphered in the 1950s, Linear A remains unreadable even though thousands of samples exist.

Understanding this script could reveal crucial information about one of the Mediterranean’s most influential early civilizations that largely disappeared around 1450 BCE.

Lost Library of Alexandria

Image Credit: Flickr by Phillip Hughes

Once the greatest collection of knowledge in the ancient world, this legendary library’s destruction represents an incalculable loss of historical, scientific, and literary works. No one knows exactly how or when the library met its end, with theories blaming Julius Caesar, religious conflicts, or gradual decline over centuries.

Scholars can only speculate about what irreplaceable ancient texts might have been lost forever when this intellectual center disappeared.

Oak Island Money Pit

Image Credit: Flickr by Joanna Atherton

This notorious site in Nova Scotia has swallowed fortunes and lives in countless failed attempts to reach whatever might lie at its bottom. First discovered in 1795, the pit features elaborate flood traps and multiple layers of wood platforms that suggest something valuable was deliberately hidden there.

Despite over 200 years of excavation efforts and modern technology, the original purpose of this engineering marvel and its contents remain unknown.

Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.

Codex Seraphinianus

Image Credit: Flickr by Cesar Ojeda

This modern mystery, created by Italian artist Luigi Serafini in the 1970s, intentionally mimics ancient undeciphered texts with its invented writing system and bizarre illustrations. The book appears to be an encyclopedia of an alien world with physically impossible plants, animals, and technologies.

Even the page numbering system operates on unknown mathematical principles, creating a deliberate puzzle that mirrors historical undeciphered texts.

Tamam Shud Case

Image Credit: DepositPhotos

In 1948, an unidentified man was found dead on an Australian beach with a mysterious phrase torn from a rare poetry book in his pocket. Despite extensive investigation, the man’s identity remains unknown, and a coded message found in his possession has never been deciphered.

Police investigations across multiple countries failed to identify him, while the strange circumstances surrounding his death generated theories ranging from espionage to unrequited love.

Piri Reis Map

Image Credit: Flickr by Kerani Kronik

This Ottoman naval chart from 1513 shows parts of Antarctica’s coastline with surprising accuracy despite being created centuries before the continent’s official discovery. The map reportedly compiled information from earlier sources including ancient Greek and Byzantine maps now lost to history.

Some sections depict geographic features with precision that seems impossible without modern surveying techniques, leading to intense debate about its origins.

Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.

Emerald Tablet

Image Credit: Flickr by Daviddusto

This ancient text allegedly containing the secrets of alchemy has been referenced for centuries but no confirmed original copy exists. Attributed variously to Egyptian, Greek, or Syrian origins, translations describe a mysterious green tablet inscribed with secret formulas for transmutation and enlightenment.

The famous phrase ‘as above, so below’ originates from this enigmatic text that influenced scientific and esoteric thought throughout history.

Mysterious Disappearance of Maya

Image Credit: Flickr by Hagens_world

This advanced Mesoamerican civilization experienced a rapid, widespread collapse around 900 CE, abandoning major ceremonial centers and cities across their territory. Their sophisticated society with written language, astronomical knowledge, and monumental architecture seemed to unravel within a relatively short timeframe.

Modern research points to drought, warfare, and environmental degradation as contributing factors, but the complete picture of how such a complex society disappeared so thoroughly remains elusive.

Mysteries Worth Preserving

Image Credit: DepositPhotos

These unsolved puzzles remind us that history isn’t a closed book of definitive answers but an ongoing conversation with the past. Each generation brings new technologies and perspectives to these ancient questions, sometimes solving pieces while discovering new complexities.

Perhaps some mysteries serve us better unsolved, inspiring wonder and humility as we confront the limits of our understanding and the vastness of human experience across time.

Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.

More from Go2Tutors!

DepositPhotos

Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.