25 Weirdest Things Ever Sold on eBay
eBay has been around since 1995, and in that time it has become the world’s biggest virtual yard sale. People have used it to get rid of old furniture, vintage sneakers, and broken gadgets.
But then there is the other side of eBay, the side where things get truly strange.
Here is a look at some of the most jaw-dropping items that real people actually listed, and in most cases, actually sold. Some of these will make you laugh, some will confuse you, and at least one will make you question everything you thought you knew about people.
A grilled cheese sandwich shaped like the Virgin Mary
In 2004, a Florida woman named Diana Duyser listed a 10-year-old grilled cheese sandwich she had been keeping in a plastic case. She said she spotted the face of the Virgin Mary in the toast shortly after making it.
The sandwich, which never grew a single spot of mold according to Duyser, sold for $28,000. GoldenPalace.com, an online casino known for buying weird items, placed the winning bid.
The sandwich went on a worldwide publicity tour after that, which is more than most sandwiches can say.
A ghost in a jar
In 2003, a man from Kirkland, Washington listed what he described as a ghost he had captured inside a small glass jar. He claimed the ghost caused bad things to happen in his home and that he wanted it gone.
Bidding went through the roof, attracting massive online attention, and the jar eventually sold for over $50,000. Whether there was actually a ghost inside is a matter of personal belief, but someone clearly paid good money on the chance that there was.
Justin Timberlake’s half-eaten French toast
A morning radio show host in New York saved a piece of French toast that Justin Timberlake had left behind during an interview in 2000. She listed it on eBay with the fork and the syrup container as part of the package.
A 19-year-old fan bought the whole thing for $1,025. The toast was reportedly still in its original state, uneaten portion and all, which raises more questions than answers.
A man’s forehead as advertising space
A man named Andrew Fischer from Nebraska auctioned off his forehead in 2005. The deal was simple: whoever won could have their logo or brand tattooed temporarily on his forehead for 30 days.
SnoreStop, a company that makes anti-snoring products, won the bid at $37,375. Fischer wore the logo on his forehead for a month and the stunt got covered by news outlets all over the world.
Sometimes the weirdest marketing ideas are the ones that actually work.
An imaginary friend
A seller once listed an ‘invisible friend’ named Jon Malipieman on eBay. The listing described Jon’s personality in detail, including his favorite foods and his general temperament.
The seller claimed Jon would travel to wherever the buyer lived and be their companion. The item sold for around $3,000.
At least with this purchase, storage costs were zero.
A UFO detector
Someone listed a device they called a ‘UFO detector’ on eBay, claiming it would alert the owner whenever an unidentified flying object was nearby. The product description was detailed and surprisingly convincing.
Dozens of bids came in, and the device sold for several hundred dollars. Whether it actually detected anything after delivery remains, fittingly, a mystery.
The meaning of life
A seller in Australia listed ‘the meaning of life’ as an eBay item. The listing was intentionally vague, describing the item as something that would be emailed to the buyer upon purchase.
eBay removed the listing more than once, but it kept coming back in slightly different forms. One version reportedly sold before being pulled.
The buyer’s review was not included in the listing, which is perhaps the most suspicious part of all.
A piece of air from a Kanye West concert
After a Kanye West concert, someone collected air from the venue in a small sealed bag and listed it on eBay. The description promised that the air had been ‘breathed in the same room as Kanye.’
The listing attracted thousands of views and serious bids from fans. It eventually sold for several hundred dollars.
That is, objectively, just air in a bag.
A haunted painting called ‘The Hands Resist Him’
In 2000, a California couple listed a painting they said was causing strange things to happen in their home. The painting, created by artist Bill Stoneham in 1972, showed a young boy and a doll standing in front of a glass door.
The sellers included a warning that the figures in the painting moved at night and that small children and those with heart problems should not view it. It sold for $1,025 and went on to become one of the most famous internet horror stories of the early 2000s.
A single cornflake shaped like Illinois
A couple from Virginia found a cornflake that looked remarkably like the state of Illinois. Instead of eating it, they sealed it in a protective case and listed it on eBay.
The listing described the cornflake’s uncanny geographical resemblance in great detail. It sold for $1,350.
The cornflake has since been nicknamed the ‘Cornflake of State Fame,’ which is a title no cornflake ever asked for.
William Shatner’s kidney stone
In 2006, actor William Shatner, known for playing Captain Kirk in Star Trek, sold one of his kidney stones on eBay. He said he wanted the proceeds to go to a housing charity, and GoldenPalace.com, the same online casino from the grilled cheese story, won the bid for $25,000.
The stone was reportedly handed over in person. This might be the only time a kidney stone raised money for a good cause.
A town in California
In 2002, a man named Don Samson listed the entire town of Bridgeville, California on eBay. The town came with a post office, several homes, and about 83 acres of land.
It sold for $1.77 million, making it one of the most valuable eBay sales ever at the time. The town has actually been relisted and resold multiple times since then.
Buying a town sounds impressive until you realize it also comes with a town’s worth of problems.
The world’s most expensive potato chip
In 2012, a woman in Missouri found a potato chip that looked exactly like Abraham Lincoln in profile. She listed it on eBay with photos clearly showing the resemblance.
The chip sold for around $400, which works out to a very steep price per ounce. The buyer paid more for that single chip than most people spend on an entire bag of groceries.
A woman’s life
In 2008, a woman in Australia named Nicola Hurley listed her entire life on eBay after going through a divorce. The package included her home, her car, her job contacts, and even introductions to her friends.
She wanted a fresh start and figured eBay was as good a place as any to find one. The winning bid was around $400,000, and the buyer, a British man, reportedly followed through on the purchase.
It remains one of the most unusual life decisions ever made via online auction.
A piece of Princess Diana’s wedding cake
A small slice of cake from Prince Charles and Princess Diana’s 1981 royal wedding was sold on eBay in 2014 for $1,375. The cake had been carefully preserved for over three decades and came with its original packaging and ribbons.
Several royal-themed food items have sold on eBay over the years, but this one stood out for its age and the sheer amount of history attached to it. Someone now owns a piece of cake that is older than most smartphones.
A British teenager’s forehead (again, advertising space)
Inspired by Andrew Fischer’s forehead stunt, a British 18-year-old named Rik Clay auctioned his own forehead as advertising space shortly after. He sold the rights for around $6,600 and wore a temporary tattoo for the agreed-upon time.
Apparently the forehead rental market was briefly competitive in the mid-2000s. It is the kind of business idea that only works once, unless you keep your head down about it.
A Dorito shaped like the Pope’s hat
A Dorito chip shaped like a papal mitre, the tall pointed hat worn by the Pope, sold on eBay for $1,209 in 2008. The seller presented careful photographic evidence of the resemblance, and bidders clearly found it convincing.
It was listed under the name ‘Pope’s Hat Dorito,’ which is not something Frito-Lay ever planned as a product line. Somewhere out there, someone has this chip on display.
A lunch date with Warren Buffett
For years, the right to have lunch with billionaire investor Warren Buffett was auctioned on eBay to raise money for the Glide Foundation, a charity in San Francisco. The price climbed dramatically year after year, eventually hitting $19 million in 2019 when an anonymous buyer won the bid.
The winner would get a private lunch with Buffett at a New York steakhouse with up to seven guests. It started as a quirky charity idea in 2000 and turned into one of the most expensive single eBay transactions ever recorded.
A broken laser pointer
Not everything weird on eBay costs thousands of dollars. Someone once listed a broken laser pointer with a description so entertaining and self-aware that it attracted hundreds of bids far above what the item was worth.
The listing admitted the pointer was completely non-functional and compared its usefulness to ‘a very small, expensive stick.’ The final price beat many working laser pointers sold that same day.
Good writing, it turns out, sells.
A chance to name a character in a video game
Game developers and book authors have occasionally auctioned off the rights to name a character in an upcoming project on eBay. Buyers would pay hundreds or even thousands of dollars to have their name, or the name of a loved one, immortalized in a fictional world.
One such listing for a role-playing game reportedly sold for over $2,500. It is one of the stranger ways to achieve a kind of immortality.
Pope John Paul II’s old car
A 1975 Fiat 126 once owned by the late Pope John Paul II, before he became Pope, was auctioned on eBay by a Polish priest. The car had been blessed by the Pope himself and attracted buyers from across the world.
It sold for an amount well over its original value simply because of who used to own it. The Fiat 126 is not a luxury vehicle by any stretch, but this particular one had a story no Ferrari could match.
A soul
In 2008, a young woman from Michigan named Lori listed her soul on eBay. The listing stated that she was not using it and was willing to pass it along for a reasonable price.
eBay removed the listing, as it does with all soul-related listings due to policy violations involving intangible items. Before it was pulled, the bidding had climbed to over $200.
eBay has a rule about this, which means enough people tried it to make a rule necessary.
An entire country’s naming rights
In 2006, a man listed the rights to rename an entire small nation on eBay. The listing was creative and detailed, describing exactly what the buyer would receive, including informal recognition and a certificate.
eBay pulled the listing before it could be completed, but not before it attracted enormous media coverage. It is the most ambitious thing ever listed in the ‘real estate’ category.
New Zealand
One teenage Aussie, only seventeen at the time, tossed New Zealand onto eBay back in 2006 – starting price? Just a single Australian cent.
Bids climbed fast, creeping past hundreds of thousands before the site finally stepped in and pulled the page down. Officials across the Tasman didn’t lose sleep; they laughed it off instead.
News outlets around the world picked up the stunt almost instantly. Though nothing changed hands, for a short while, an actual dollar figure hung over the nation – one that few others ever get to see attached to their borders.
A piece of toast with an imprint of a Wi-Fi symbol
A single slice of bread showed what looked like a Wi-Fi logo seared right onto it. This one got photographed from every direction, laid out like something sacred.
Someone wrote about it without a hint of irony – gave exact dimensions, crisp pictures, full detail. Bidding pushed past sixty bucks before it closed.
These days, staying linked seems to carry a kind of worship all on its own.
eBay Is the World’s Strangest Collection of Odd Things
A marketplace meant for ordinary trades somehow became a vault for ghost stories, eerie portraits, one person’s leftover toe. Yet each odd item up for sale whispers clues – about joy, obsession, boredom clicking through at 3 AM.
A grilled cheese surviving years without rot. Breakfast bits shaped like forgotten geography.
These moments reveal how humans cling to symbols, even silly ones. Meaning pops up where least expected.
The internet handed us a place to trade it all, no questions asked.
More from Go2Tutors!
- The Romanov Crown Jewels and Their Tragic Fate
- 13 Historical Mysteries That Science Still Can’t Solve
- Famous Hoaxes That Fooled the World for Years
- 15 Child Stars with Tragic Adult Lives
- 16 Famous Jewelry Pieces in History
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.
