29 Menu Items Diners Served in the ’50s
A 1950s dinner menu was part meal and part performance. Sauces arrived in silver dishes, desserts caught fire at the table, and anything vaguely French got an accent mark.
Many of these dishes have since vanished from restaurants, and a few still turn up in grandmothers’ recipe boxes.
These twenty-nine dishes cover the appetizers, entrees, and desserts that defined mid-century dining. Some were elegant, some were thrifty, and plenty of them involved cream.
Shrimp Cocktail
Pink shrimp crowned a frosty glass, served with a red sauce typically made from ketchup, horseradish, and lemon juice. Cooks poached the shrimp briefly and shocked them in cold water for a firm snap.
The dish delivered glamour for little effort, which helps explain why it opened so many dinner parties.
Oysters Rockefeller
Antoine’s in New Orleans created this dish in 1899, baking oysters on the half shell under a rich green sauce. The name nodded to the wealth of John D. Rockefeller, since nothing else on the menu felt as luxurious.
Oysters baked under a rich sauce became a classic of the dinner party circuit.
Waldorf Salad
Oscar Tschirky, the maitre d’ of the Waldorf Hotel in New York, is credited with this salad of apples, celery, and mayonnaise. Walnuts joined the mix later and became so standard that many diners assumed they had always been there.
It was a dependable first course for a formal luncheon.
Aspic
Savory gelatin molds filled with meat or vegetables graced buffets and holiday spreads in the 1950s. The jiggling centerpiece required patience, a mold, and a refrigerator with room to spare.
It has largely vanished from restaurant menus, and few diners today would order it by choice.
Chicken à la King
Diced chicken, mushrooms, pimientos, and peas in a velvety cream sauce, usually served over toast points or rice, turned an ordinary meal into an occasion. Many people dismiss it as a pot pie without a crust, but the dish was meant to feel more refined.
It was once a cafeteria staple and is now a rarity.
Beef Stroganoff
This mid-century version of the Russian original combined strips of beef, mushrooms, and a creamy sauce over egg noodles. It was rich, filling, and easy to scale for company.
For many families it counted as the most elegant thing they could make on a weeknight.
Beef Wellington
A tender beef fillet wrapped in buttery pastry made a dramatic centerpiece for a dinner party. The appeal was the contrast between the crisp shell and the rosy interior.
In the United States it also became the subject of a craze in the 1960s.
Steak Diane
Cooks finished this steak at the table in a pan, building a sauce from the juices left behind and setting it alight with a tableside flambé. The sauce was a kitchen-sink affair, and almost anything could be added and still be called Diane.
It symbolized mid-century elegance, and it has largely disappeared as diners lost patience for tableside theater.
Salisbury Steak
The reputation of this dish has suffered because of the frozen dinners that carried its name. Cooked properly at home, as 1950s cooks often did, a ground beef patty in gravy is solid comfort food.
It was a thrifty entree that managed to look like a restaurant meal.
Duck à l’Orange
The French-sounding name made roast duck with orange sauce feel like a night out, and it was a classic 1950s dinner entree. It is far less well known today than other dishes from the same era.
Few home cooks still attempt it, and fewer restaurants keep it on the menu.
Chicken Divan
Chicken breasts and broccoli baked in Mornay sauce, a white sauce enriched with cheese, made up this casserole. It was invented at and named for the Divan Parisien Restaurant in New York City.
It was the rage in the 1950s but had vanished from most restaurant menus by the following decade.
Turkey Tetrazzini
Turkey Tetrazzini was invented in San Francisco in the early years of the twentieth century and named for the Italian soprano Luisa Tetrazzini, who made her American debut in the city in 1905. The dish combined turkey, pasta, and a creamy sauce, and it was still on 1950s menus decades after its invention.
Coquilles St. Jacques
Scallops in a creamy sauce and baked in a scallop shell were a staple of 1950s restaurants that wanted to sound French. The shell did the presenting, which meant the dish looked fancier than it was to make.
Diners ordered it as a sign that the evening was special.
Swiss Steak with Tomato Gravy
Round steak was pounded, flavored, and simmered slowly in a tomato-based gravy until tender. The cut was inexpensive, so the long cooking time did the work that cost might have done.
Despite its name, the dish has no connection to Switzerland.
Meatloaf
Meatloaf frequently graced 1950s dinner tables, and one loaf could provide several meals. It stretched a small amount of beef into a filling meal.
It has outlasted most of its mid-century peers on this list.
Tuna Noodle Casserole
Casseroles were the signature of 1950s home cooking, and tuna noodle was one of the most popular of the decade. Campbell’s home economist Dorcas Reilly, who also created green bean casserole in 1955, is credited with a version.
It combined canned tuna, noodles, and cream soup into a dish that cost very little.
Stuffed Peppers
Ground beef, rice, and tomato filled green peppers that were baked until tender. The result sliced neatly and looked good on a patterned plate.
It balanced heavier dishes at the table and used inexpensive ingredients.
Creamed Chipped Beef
Dried beef in a cream sauce was spooned over potatoes, and sometimes over toast. It was salty and filling, which made it a popular choice for a quick supper.
Few restaurants serve it now.
Baked Haddock with Crumb Topping
Mild white fish was baked under a crumb topping, a typical home dinner of the decade. The topping gave the fish some texture.
As fresh seafood and different flavors became popular, the dish faded.
Chicken Pot Pie with Biscuit Lids
Instead of a full crust, many 1950s home cooks topped their pot pies with biscuit dough. It baked quickly and used pantry staples.
The shortcut gave the dish its distinctive fluffy lid.
Baked Macaroni
Macaroni was set in a ring mold with a meat filling in the center. The shape was the point, since a ring on a platter looked more impressive than a casserole dish.
It has almost entirely disappeared from home cooking.
Sautéed Calf’s Liver
Restaurants served calf’s liver sautéed and often topped with onions or bacon. At home, cooks seared beef liver and served it with a bacon-based gravy, treating it as a nutrient-focused meal.
The dish was once common, and now many diners avoid it.
Lemon Chiffon Pie
Lemon chiffon pie was a light, airy filling lifted with beaten egg whites and set with gelatin. It was a popular 1950s restaurant dessert.
The texture was the draw, soft enough to be cloud-like but firm enough to slice.
Strawberry Shortcake
Strawberries, whipped cream, and a tender biscuit or sponge made a dessert that worked in any season restaurants could find berries. It was a lighter finish after a heavy meal.
It remains familiar today, unlike many dishes on this list.
Baked Alaska
Baked Alaska sent gasps around the table and then silence as spoons dug in. A layer of ice cream sat on cake, and everything was covered in meringue and briefly browned.
It remained a popular showpiece, and diners still talk about it when it appears.
Cherries Jubilee
This dessert combined cherries and brandy and was set aflame at the table. The fiery presentation made it a mid-century marvel.
Today, spotting it on a menu is like finding a culinary relic.
Bananas Foster
Brennan’s in New Orleans created bananas Foster in 1951, naming it for Richard Foster, a friend of the restaurant’s owner. Bananas were cooked in butter, sugar, and rum and flambéed at the table.
It was a perfect dessert for the decade because it combined fire, sweetness, and showmanship.
Pineapple Upside-Down Cake
Caramelized pineapple rings topped with bright red cherries made this cake a 1950s sensation. The visual presentation was the main attraction, since the cake was flipped to reveal the pattern.
It was a dependable dessert for church suppers and dinner tables alike.
When Dinner Was Theater
The 1950s menu rewarded presentation. Tableside flames, molded shapes, and rich sauces told diners that a meal was an event instead of a necessity.
Even the thrifty dishes borrowed that flair, dressing cheap ingredients in cream and a French name.
Tastes eventually moved toward lighter, simpler food, and most of these dishes drifted off restaurant menus. A few lasted because they were easy to love, and others survive as curiosities.
The best of them still make a convincing case that dinner can be an occasion.
More from Go2Tutors!
- The Romanov Crown Jewels and Their Tragic Fate
- 13 Historical Mysteries That Science Still Can’t Solve
- Famous Hoaxes That Fooled the World for Years
- 15 Child Stars with Tragic Adult Lives
- 16 Famous Jewelry Pieces in History
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.
