Hit Songs Written by Surprising Artists
The music industry loves a good secret.
While we belt out our favorite songs in the car or shower, most of us assume the artist singing wrote every word.
But the reality behind the scenes tells a different story.
Some of the biggest hits in music history were actually penned by entirely different artists, and the stories behind these songs are often as fascinating as the tracks themselves.
Here is a list of hit songs written by surprising artists that might just change how you hear them.
Nothing Compares 2 U
When Sinead O’Connor’s haunting ballad topped charts in 14 countries in 1990, most listeners had no idea Prince was behind it.
He’d written and recorded the song back in 1984 during his Purple Rain glory days, then handed it off to his side project The Family, where it flopped.
O’Connor’s manager suggested she cover it as a tribute to her late mother, and she nailed the vocals in just one take.
That iconic music video with the single tear rolling down her cheek made the song hers forever, even though Prince wrote it about his housekeeper quitting.
Manic Monday
Prince strikes again with this Bangles classic that perfectly captures that Monday morning dread.
He originally wrote it for Apollonia 6 in 1984, but after catching The Bangles live in LA, he decided they’d be a better fit.
The band completely reworked his demo to give it their signature sound, and the gamble paid off when it peaked at number two on the Billboard Hot 100.
Funny enough, it was kept from the top spot by another Prince song—’Kiss.’
Party in the U.S.A.
Before Jessie J became a pop star in her own right, she was grinding it out as a songwriter trying to pay rent in London.
She co-wrote this anthem with Dr. Luke and Claude Kelly, hoping to record it herself, but her label passed.
Instead, it went to Miley Cyrus, who was looking to shed her Disney Channel image, and the song exploded.
Jessie J later admitted the royalties from this single track paid her rent for three straight years, which is why she kept writing for others even after finding solo success.
Irreplaceable
‘To the left, to the left’—those iconic lyrics came straight from Ne-Yo’s pen, not Beyoncé’s.
He was a rising R&B star himself when he wrote this breakup anthem, originally as a country song before it got reworked into the pop masterpiece we know.
The song’s message about easily replacing a guy who doesn’t appreciate you resonated so hard it became one of Beyoncé’s signature hits.
Ne-Yo was in high demand as a songwriter at the time, and this track proved exactly why.
Love Yourself
Ed Sheeran wrote this for Justin Bieber’s Purpose album, and the stripped-down acoustic vibe shows his fingerprints all over it.
The song’s brutally honest lyrics about a toxic relationship helped Bieber mature his image beyond teen heartthrob status.
Sheeran even appears on Bieber’s track, trading vocals in what became a genuine collaboration.
It’s one of those rare cases where the songwriter and performer both brought something essential to make it work.
Halo
Ryan Tedder from OneRepublic crafted this uplifting Beyoncé anthem in just three hours with his friend Evan Bogart.
Tedder’s wife had gone out for the evening, so he called up Bogart asking if he wanted to write ‘one song,’ and they ended up creating one of the biggest ballads of 2008.
The song’s soaring chorus and heartfelt lyrics about finding your person became a wedding favorite almost overnight.
Tedder was literally standing onstage with Taylor Swift when she won Album of the Year in 2016, proof that his behind-the-scenes work rivals his own band’s success.
Pretty Hurts
Australian singer-songwriter Sia wrote this powerful ballad about eating disorders and beauty standards with Katy Perry in mind.
She sent Perry an email offering her first dibs, but when Perry missed the message, the song ended up in a bidding war between Rihanna and Beyoncé.
After Rihanna’s team dragged their feet for eight months, Beyoncé’s team swooped in and secured it for her self-titled album.
The track’s raw vulnerability and feminist themes made it a standout, even though it came from outside Beyoncé’s usual songwriting team.
Diamonds
Sia scored her first number-one hit as a songwriter with this Rihanna track from the Unapologetic album.
The success of ‘Diamonds’ not only elevated Sia’s status as an in-demand songwriter but also pushed Rihanna into new musical territory with its more introspective tone.
Sia was still writing primarily for other artists at this point, building the reputation that would eventually launch her own solo career.
The song’s message about shining bright like diamonds became an instant cultural touchstone.
We Found Love
Scottish DJ and producer Calvin Harris is known for cranking out dance hits, but many people don’t realize he’s the mastermind behind this Rihanna banger.
The song took over radio stations, department stores, and dance clubs everywhere in the early 2010s, becoming nearly impossible to escape.
Harris has made a career of staying behind the scenes while his songs dominate the charts.
This collaboration with Rihanna proved he could create not just club tracks but genuine pop phenomena.
Islands in the Stream
The Bee Gees wrote every song on Diana Ross’s ‘Eaten Alive’ album, including this duet that they decided to pitch to Kenny Rogers and Dolly Parton instead.
Rogers and Parton’s version became their second number-one hit, perfectly blending their distinctive voices into country-pop gold.
The song almost didn’t make it to release because it closely matched Ross’s earlier Supremes sound, but luckily someone had second thoughts.
The Bee Gees were in their post-disco era, focusing on writing for others, and this track became one of their most successful contributions.
I Don’t Want to Miss a Thing
Aerosmith needed a power ballad for the Armageddon soundtrack, but the band was burnt out from touring.
Enter Diane Warren, the power ballad writing queen, who’d originally written this as a female piano ballad for someone else.
When Aerosmith cut a demo, the label loved it so much they pushed for it to be the lead single.
The song became Aerosmith’s first and only number-one hit, proving sometimes the best fit comes from unexpected places.
Red Red Wine
UB40 had no clue they were covering a Neil Diamond song when they recorded this reggae version in 1983.
When they saw the writing credit ‘N. Diamond,’ they genuinely thought it was a Jamaican artist named Negus Diamond.
The band only knew the song from Tony Tribe’s 1969 reggae cover, which had been a hit in the UK.
Their version became a massive success, and Diamond himself has praised their interpretation as bringing new life to his 1967 original.
Umbrella
The-Dream co-wrote this career-defining hit for Rihanna’s Good Girl Gone Bad album, the record that transformed her from pop princess to legitimate superstar.
The song’s metaphor about lovers supporting each other through anything they face resonated globally and dominated 2007.
The-Dream was simultaneously working on his own debut album Love/Hate, proving he could create hits for himself and others.
That ‘ella, ella, ella’ hook became so iconic it’s still instantly recognizable nearly two decades later.
Forget You
Bruno Mars co-wrote this CeeLo Green smash hit about a gold digger and her new flame, giving it that retro-soul vibe that defined 2010.
The song’s cheeky attitude and infectious melody share DNA with Mars’s own style, making his involvement unsurprising in hindsight.
Mars has quietly built an impressive songwriting catalog beyond his own hits, including work for Adele.
This track showcased his ability to craft songs that feel both timeless and contemporary.
Take a Bow
Babyface co-wrote and co-produced this smooth ballad for Madonna’s Bedtime Stories album when she wanted to soften her image.
The song finds Madonna reflecting on a relationship that’s run its course, delivered with a restraint that was new for her at the time.
It became Madonna’s 11th chart-topper on the Billboard Hot 100, proving her artistic reinvention worked.
Babyface’s R&B sensibilities gave the track a sophistication that expanded Madonna’s sound beyond pure pop.
…Baby One More Time
TLC was offered this track first, but T-Boz flat-out refused to sing the line ‘hit me baby one more time,’ thinking it sounded ridiculous.
The girl group passed, and the song landed with a young Britney Spears instead, launching her into instant superstardom.
T-Boz later said she doesn’t regret the decision, explaining that ‘every song isn’t good for each artist,’ though she admits it was clearly a hit.
Sometimes the wrong fit for one artist becomes the perfect launching pad for another.
When Songs Find Their True Home
The music industry’s songwriting economy proves that sometimes the best person to perform a song isn’t the person who wrote it.
These tracks show how a songwriter’s vision can transform when filtered through a different artist’s voice and style.
From Prince’s generous habit of gifting away masterpieces to Jessie J’s rent-paying hit, the stories behind these songs reveal a collaborative art form where egos take a backseat to creating something special.
The next time you hear a song that moves you, remember there might be a fascinating story about who actually put pen to paper, and that story often makes the music even richer.
More from Go2Tutors!
- The Romanov Crown Jewels and Their Tragic Fate
- 13 Historical Mysteries That Science Still Can’t Solve
- Famous Hoaxes That Fooled the World for Years
- 15 Child Stars with Tragic Adult Lives
- 16 Famous Jewelry Pieces in History
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.
