14 ‘Unfinished’ Songs That Became Chart Hits Anyway
The music industry is full of happy accidents and unexpected successes. Sometimes the most imperfect creations resonate more deeply with audiences than meticulously polished productions. Artists occasionally release tracks they consider incomplete or flawed, only to watch them soar up the charts and connect with listeners worldwide.
Here is a list of 14 songs that weren’t quite “finished” according to their creators but managed to become massive hits anyway.
Gimme Shelter by The Rolling Stones
The apocalyptic masterpiece features a legendary vocal performance by Merry Clayton, who sang with such intensity that her voice cracked during the recording. That vocal break remained in the final version, with Mick Jagger audibly shouting “Woo!” in appreciation during the take.
The Stones could have re-recorded it but decided the raw emotion captured something special they couldn’t replicate.
Love Will Tear Us Apart by Joy Division
This post-punk classic was recorded in a rush during the band’s final studio session before singer Ian Curtis’s death. The band never had time to refine the mix to their satisfaction.
Producer Martin Hannett later mentioned they planned to revisit and polish the track, but Curtis’s suicide meant the “rough mix” became the official release. The song became Joy Division’s most enduring hit.
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN
Time After Time by Cyndi Lauper
Cyndi Lauper wrote this ballad literally at the last minute when her producer insisted the album needed one more track. She composed it overnight with songwriter Rob Hyman, and they recorded a demo with temporary lyrics and melody sections.
The record company loved the demo so much that they released it almost exactly as recorded. The “unfinished” song became Lauper’s first number one hit.
Dancing Queen by ABBA
The Swedish pop group intended to include a bridge section in this disco classic. They recorded the track and even composed the additional part, but producer Stig Anderson convinced them to release it without the bridge.
The band members later expressed regret about the omission, but the streamlined version became their only U.S. number-one hit.
Under Pressure by Queen and David Bowie
This iconic collaboration came from an impromptu jam session when Bowie visited Queen in their Swiss studio. The famous bassline was improvised by John Deacon, and the vocals were largely spontaneous.
Both Bowie and Freddie Mercury wanted to rework the track with additional instrumentation and structure, but deadlines forced them to release what was essentially an elaborate demo. The unpolished track topped charts worldwide.
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN
Like a Rolling Stone by Bob Dylan
Dylan’s groundbreaking six-minute track was recorded with session musicians who had never played together before. The final take used for the record was only the fourth attempt, with producer Tom Wilson choosing it despite several musical mistakes.
Dylan later admitted he’d planned to refine the lyrics and arrangement but the raw energy of that early take proved impossible to improve upon.
Hey Jude by The Beatles
Paul McCartney wrote this as a comforting song for Julian Lennon during his parents’ divorce. The original recording features a mistake at the mark where someone says “wrong chord!” faintly in the background.
The band planned to fix this and other minor errors, but deadlines forced them to release the track as-is. The imperfect version became the Beatles’ longest-running number one hit.
Smells Like Teen Spirit by Nirvana
Kurt Cobain considered this anthem incomplete, with placeholder lyrics he never refined. The song’s structure was deliberately simple, intended as a framework to be developed further.
Producer Butch Vig convinced the band to keep its raw simplicity, and the “unfinished” track launched grunge into the mainstream and defined a generation.
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN
Sweet Child O’ Mine by Guns N’ Roses
Slash’s iconic opening riff started as a warm-up exercise he was playing to loosen his fingers. The band built the song around this “throwaway” riff, and Axl Rose quickly added lyrics he’d written for a different project.
The unusual outro with its “where do we go now?” refrain was improvised when they couldn’t decide how to end the song. This hastily assembled track became their only number one single.
(I Can’t Get No) Satisfaction by The Rolling Stones
Keith Richards recorded the famous guitar riff on a cassette recorder while half-asleep, then promptly fell back asleep. The next morning, he discovered the recording contained the riff followed by minutes of snoring.
The band quickly recorded the song with a fuzzy guitar tone that Richards intended to replace with a horn section later. The temporary guitar version was released instead and became their breakthrough hit.
Dreams by Fleetwood Mac
Stevie Nicks wrote this song in about minutes during a break from the Rumours album sessions. The band recorded it quickly with minimal arrangement as a rough demo.
Other band members initially dismissed it as too simple and unfinished, but producer Ken Caillat convinced them to release it nearly unchanged. The stripped-down track became their only number one U.S. hit.
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN
Strawberry Fields Forever by The Beatles
John Lennon couldn’t decide between two completely different versions of this psychedelic masterpiece. Producer George Martin solved the dilemma by splicing the two takes together, even though they were recorded in different keys and tempos.
This technically “unfinished” composite became one of their most innovative recordings and influenced production techniques for decades.
Rock and Roll All Nite by KISS
This anthem was cobbled together from two incomplete song fragments when their producer demanded a signature hit for their album. Gene Simmons and Paul Stanley combined their separate ideas in less than a day, and the band recorded it immediately.
The studio version didn’t chart well, but a live version from their Alive! album became their breakthrough hit despite its rough edges.
Somebody That I Used to Know by Gotye
Gotye built this song around a sample from an old Brazilian guitar recording. He considered the production rudimentary and planned to re-record many elements, but his label pushed for release after hearing the demo.
The minimal arrangement and unpolished feel became its signature sound, and the song topped charts in over countries despite its creator’s concerns about its completeness.
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN
The Imperfect Magic of Music
These songs remind us that music often works best when it captures genuine moments rather than pursuing technical perfection. The rough edges, happy accidents, and spontaneous decisions often create the character that connects most deeply with listeners.
What artists sometimes view as flaws can become the very elements that make a track timeless.
For every meticulously crafted hit, there are these beautiful accidents—songs that weren’t quite “ready” but somehow found their perfect form in their imperfection. They stand as testaments to the unpredictable magic that happens when creativity meets opportunity, even when the creator thinks the work isn’t quite done.
More from Go2Tutors!
- 18 Unexpectedly Valuable Collectibles You Might Have Lying Around
- 15 Things Every Teenager in the ’70s Did That Teens Today Wouldn’t Understand
- 15 Strange Things People Have Tried to Ban (And Failed)
- 15 Inventions That Were Immediately Banned After Being Created
- 20 Actors Who Were Almost Cast in Iconic Roles
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN
