23 Books That Were Banned For Centuries Before Becoming Required Reading
There is something almost reliably predictable about book banning: the books that make people most uncomfortable at the time of publication tend to be the ones that turn out to matter most. The logic isn’t complicated. A book that threatens nobody’s understanding of the world doesn’t get burned. A book that challenges something people genuinely depend on — their sense of order, their moral framework, their picture of the universe — provokes a response proportional to how much it unsettles them.
The books below were all, at some point, genuinely dangerous in the eyes of someone with the power to suppress them. Most of them are now on high school reading lists.
Ulysses — James Joyce (1922)
James Joyce’s novel was declared obscene by the New York Society for the Suppression of Vice in 1920, while it was still being serialised in the literary magazine The Little Review. A court declared it pornographic in 1921 and copies were seized and burned.
For over a decade, no American publisher would touch it. The ban was finally overturned in 1933 when Judge John Woolsey, in a ruling that became a landmark of First Amendment law, declared that the novel’s depictions of human consciousness were not obscene but were literary.
The book is now widely considered the greatest novel written in the English language in the 20th century and is compulsory reading in most university English programmes.
Lady Chatterley’s Lover — D.H. Lawrence (1928)
D.H. Lawrence’s novel about an aristocratic woman’s affair with her gamekeeper could not be published in England in its complete form upon his death — Lawrence had it printed privately in Florence, selling the entire first run of 1,000 copies immediately.
An uncensored American edition published by Grove Press in 1959 prompted an obscenity trial, and the 1960 UK trial by Penguin Books became one of the most famous courtroom dramas in literary history. The prosecution famously asked the jury whether the book was one they would wish “your wife or your servants” to read.
Penguin won. The book sold 2 million copies in the six weeks following the verdict, and poet Philip Larkin later marked it as the moment when British intimate culture changed.
Candide — Voltaire (1759)
Voltaire published Candide anonymously in 1759, and it was immediately banned in Catholic Paris and Calvinist Geneva simultaneously — an impressive feat for a single book. The French authorities found its religious skepticism intolerable; the Genevans found its satire of their city offensive.
American customs seized copies as obscene well into the 20th century. The book’s argument — that the philosophical optimism of Leibniz (“this is the best of all possible worlds”) was a comfortable delusion in a world containing earthquakes, slavery, and war — was too sharp to be tolerated.
It is now one of the most frequently assigned texts in introductory university philosophy and literature courses worldwide.
Tropic Of Cancer — Henry Miller (1934)
Henry Miller’s memoir-novel about his impoverished years in Paris could only be published in France in 1934, by Obelisk Press, an outlet better known for pornography.
American customs banned it immediately, and for nearly three decades it circulated on the black market in the United States while being borrowed from foreign editions by writers who called it one of the most important American books of the century.
The ban was not lifted until 1964, after a Florida case reached the Supreme Court, which ruled it non-obscene in a decision that fundamentally changed American censorship law. It is now taught in most American university literature programmes.
The Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn — Mark Twain (1884)
Mark Twain’s novel was banned by the Concord Public Library in Massachusetts just one month after publication in 1885 on the grounds that it was “rough, coarse and inelegant” and contained “not a single redeeming quality.”
The library described it as “the veriest trash.” Twain reportedly enjoyed the ban enormously, noting that it would sell another 25,000 copies.
The book has never stopped being challenged — it was removed from school curricula in several American districts as recently as the 2010s, now primarily for its use of racial language.
It is simultaneously one of the most frequently challenged books in American educational history and one of the most frequently assigned, appearing on virtually every list of foundational American literature.
To Kill A Mockingbird — Harper Lee (1960)
Harper Lee’s novel won the Pulitzer Prize in 1961 and was adapted into an Academy Award-winning film in 1962. It has also been one of the most challenged books in American school libraries for decades.
It was banned or removed from curricula in various districts for its language, its racial content, and its frank portrayal of racial injustice in the American South. Several California school districts removed it from required reading lists in 2022.
It remains simultaneously one of the most frequently taught and most frequently challenged novels in the American educational system, a contradiction that captures the specific discomfort the book was always designed to produce.
The Catcher In The Rye — J.D. Salinger (1951)
A high school teacher was fired in 1960 for assigning J.D. Salinger’s novel to an 11th-grade class — a consequence sufficiently severe that it illustrates the cultural climate the book operated in.
The novel’s narrator Holden Caulfield, with his contempt for “phoniness” and his frank discussion of depression and alienation, was considered a dangerous influence on adolescent readers.
It was banned in multiple US school districts, challenged repeatedly through the 1970s and 1980s, and briefly associated with two high-profile murders because both John Lennon’s killer and the man who shot Ronald Reagan were found to be carrying copies.
It is now studied in almost every American high school English programme.
1984 — George Orwell (1949)
George Orwell’s novel about a totalitarian surveillance state was banned in the Soviet Union for reasons that hardly require explanation. It was also banned by the United States Information Agency from its overseas libraries in the early Cold War period on the grounds that it depicted socialism in unflattering terms that might be counterproductive to American foreign policy goals — an irony Orwell would likely have appreciated.
It has been challenged in various American school districts for its intimate content and political themes. It is now the most frequently assigned political novel in English-language education worldwide, and its vocabulary — Big Brother, doublethink, Room 101, Newspeak — has entered the common language of political criticism.
Brave New World — Aldous Huxley (1932)
Aldous Huxley’s dystopia was banned in Ireland shortly after publication and remained on school challenge lists in the United States for decades for its depictions of promiscuity, drugs, and its implicit criticism of Christianity.
Unlike Orwell’s 1984, Huxley’s world is not maintained through fear but through pleasure — a vision of social control through consumption and engineered contentment that the novel’s critics found either too shocking or, eventually, too accurate.
It is now one of the two canonical dystopian novels in English education, paired in virtually every curriculum with 1984 and studied for what the two texts together reveal about how societies choose to maintain power.
Fahrenheit 451 — Ray Bradbury (1953)
A novel about the burning of books was itself banned from several American schools. Bradbury’s dystopia — in which professional “firemen” burn books that contain dangerous ideas — was challenged and removed from school reading lists in various districts primarily for its language.
A specific irony: some school editions of the novel were published with words altered or removed to make the book acceptable for school use, which Bradbury found sufficiently insulting that he demanded Ballantine Books restore the original text.
A novel about censorship was being censored. He required the publisher’s compliance before his death in 2012, and the original text is now the standard school edition.
The Grapes Of Wrath — John Steinbeck (1939)
John Steinbeck’s novel about migrant workers during the Great Depression won the Pulitzer Prize in 1940 and was banned or burned in several California counties — including Kern County, which is explicitly depicted in the book — on the grounds that it defamed the state and unfairly characterised local farmers.
Some copies were publicly burned. The Associated Farmers of Kern County argued that the book was communist propaganda and arranged a campaign to have it removed from libraries.
It was also banned in East St. Louis, Illinois. It is now a foundational text of American literature and is studied in most American high school curricula as a defining document of the Great Depression era.
Native Son — Richard Wright (1940)
Richard Wright’s novel about a young Black man in Chicago was a Book of the Month Club selection in 1940 — making it one of the first works by a Black author to achieve that status — and became a bestseller.
It was also banned from libraries across the American South and challenged repeatedly for its portrayal of racial violence and its frank critique of structural racism.
Several school districts banned it as recently as 2011 for what challengers described as offensive language and violence. Wright intended the discomfort.
He wrote in his introduction that he wanted the novel to be a live grenade placed in the lap of American culture, and by most measures he succeeded.
The Color Purple — Alice Walker (1982)
Alice Walker’s Pulitzer Prize-winning novel has been one of the most frequently challenged books in American libraries since its publication.
It was removed or challenged in multiple school districts for its language, its depictions of abuse, and its portrayal of lesbian relationships. A California school district banned it from middle school reading lists in 1984, two years after publication and the same year it won the Pulitzer.
It was challenged in Saginaw, Michigan, in 1987, and in various other districts throughout the 1990s. It is now widely taught in American high schools and universities as a major work of American fiction and as a central text in courses on African American literature and women’s writing.
All Quiet On The Western Front — Erich Maria Remarque (1929)
Erich Maria Remarque’s anti-war novel was a global bestseller on publication — selling 2.5 million copies in its first year — and was publicly burned by the Nazis in Germany in 1933, with Joseph Goebbels overseeing the burning of copies at the Berlin book burnings.
It was banned in Nazi Germany, Italy under Mussolini, and Austria. Remarque himself was stripped of his German citizenship.
The novel’s depiction of World War I as a dehumanising catastrophe rather than a heroic campaign was precisely what made it dangerous to governments preparing for the next war.
It is now taught in secondary schools across Europe and the United States as the defining literary testimony of World War I.
The Satanic Verses — Salman Rushdie (1988)
Salman Rushdie’s novel was banned in India after it was published in the UK — the Indian government citing potential social disorder — and banned in several other Muslim-majority countries upon publication.
In February 1989, Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khomeini issued a fatwa declaring Rushdie’s death permissible and offering a bounty. Rushdie went into hiding under British police protection for nearly a decade.
The book’s Japanese translator was murdered; its Italian and Norwegian translators were stabbed. Rushdie himself survived a near-fatal stabbing in New York in 2022.
Despite the violence surrounding it, the novel is now widely studied in university literature and postcolonial studies programmes as a central text of late 20th-century fiction.
Beloved — Toni Morrison (1987)
Toni Morrison’s novel about a formerly enslaved woman haunted by the ghost of the baby she killed to prevent her from being taken back into slavery won the Pulitzer Prize in 1988 and is widely considered one of the great American novels.
It has also been challenged and removed from school reading lists repeatedly for its depictions of violence, abuse, and what some challengers described as disturbing content.
Parents in Virginia challenged it in 2016 after a student reportedly developed emotional disturbance from reading it, leading to a state law requiring parental notification before assigning books with “sexually explicit” content.
The book was assigned in a high school Advanced Placement course. It is now required reading in most serious American literature programmes at the university level.
Animal Farm — George Orwell (1945)
George Orwell finished Animal Farm in 1943, and it was rejected by four British publishers — including Victor Gollancz, T.S. Eliot at Faber and Faber, and Jonathan Cape — not because of its literary quality but because it was considered politically inopportune to criticise the Soviet Union while Britain and the USSR were wartime allies.
Orwell documented the rejections in his 1946 essay “The Freedom of the Press,” itself suppressed as a preface to the book. Once published, the novel was banned in the Soviet Union and other communist states.
It is now one of the most commonly assigned books in English-language secondary education worldwide.
Howl — Allen Ginsberg (1956)
Allen Ginsberg’s long poem was seized by United States customs officers when copies were shipped from the printer in London, and San Francisco police arrested the manager of City Lights Bookstore for selling it in 1957.
The resulting obscenity trial, Howl on Trial, attracted testimony from literary scholars and became a defining moment in American free speech law.
Judge Clayton Horn ruled that the poem had “redeeming social importance” and acquitted the bookseller. The poem is now taught in virtually every American survey of 20th-century poetry as the foundational text of the Beat movement.
The Diary Of A Young Girl — Anne Frank (1947)
Anne Frank’s diary has been challenged and removed from school curricula in multiple American districts, most recently in a Texas school district in 2021, primarily for passages describing Anne’s own developing body that she wrote in her diary with the expectation that no one else would read them.
It is simultaneously one of the most commonly assigned books in Holocaust education worldwide and one of the most frequently challenged books in American school libraries.
The grounds for challenge — a young girl writing privately about puberty in a diary later published without her knowledge — tell you something about the specific anxiety that drives book challenges more than the content itself does.
Lord Of The Flies — William Golding (1954)
William Golding’s novel about a group of schoolboys who revert to violence when stranded on an uninhabited island was rejected by multiple publishers before being accepted by Faber and Faber.
It has since been one of the most challenged books in American schools, cited for violence, language, and inappropriate content. It has also been one of the most commonly assigned novels in English-language secondary education for the past five decades.
The specific tension the book generates — it is brutal, and the brutality is the point — makes it a good case study in what “challenging” and “required” actually mean when applied to the same text simultaneously.
The Merchant Of Venice — William Shakespeare
Shakespeare’s plays have been banned and challenged more widely and in more contexts than almost any other body of work in English.
The Merchant of Venice was banned in parts of the United States during the late 19th and early 20th centuries for its portrayal of Shylock, which some communities found offensive on antisemitic grounds — arguing either that it was antisemitic or that it encouraged antisemitism, depending on the community.
It was specifically banned from German education during the Nazi period when it was used as propaganda, and then subject to careful discussion after the war about whether it should be taught at all.
It is now a standard text in British secondary education and widely taught in university Shakespeare courses.
The Wizard Of Oz — L. Frank Baum (1900)
L. Frank Baum’s fantasy novel was banned from various American libraries in the 1920s through 1950s on several grounds that seem incoherent in retrospect.
These included its depiction of a girl who runs away from home, its suggestions that magic could be benevolent rather than satanic, and, in Detroit’s public libraries, the grounds that it was “ungodly” and contained “no value for children of today.”
The books were absent from Chicago Public Library shelves for many years. The novel is now considered one of the foundational texts of American children’s literature and is among the most recognisable stories in the English-speaking world.
I Know Why The Caged Bird Sings — Maya Angelou (1969)
Maya Angelou’s memoir about her childhood in the segregated American South has been one of the most frequently banned books in American schools since publication.
It has been challenged for its frank depiction of abuse, its language, and its portrayal of racism. In 2019, it was removed from a Virginia school district’s reading list.
In 2022, it was removed from a Texas school district. Angelou was a Presidential Medal of Freedom recipient, and the book is widely regarded as one of the most important American memoirs of the 20th century.
The grounds for its challenge have remained essentially unchanged for 55 years.
The Price Of A Silenced Voice
There is a pattern worth noticing across these twenty-three books. In almost no case was the stated reason for banning the actual reason.
Huckleberry Finn was banned as “coarse,” not as a book that made comfortable readers uncomfortable about race. Lady Chatterley’s Lover was prosecuted for obscenity, not for challenging the English class system.
All Quiet on the Western Front was burned because it told the truth about war, not because of anything objectionable about its prose. The censors were, almost without exception, protecting something other than what they said they were protecting.
The books that got banned were the ones that got something right. That’s not a romantic retrospective gloss — it’s the functional explanation for why the same books keep showing up on both the banned list and the required reading list.
They are the same list. The thing that made them dangerous is the thing that made them endure, and the authorities who tried to suppress them were accurate in their instinct even while being wrong in every possible conclusion they drew from it.
More from Go2Tutors!
- The Romanov Crown Jewels and Their Tragic Fate
- 13 Historical Mysteries That Science Still Can’t Solve
- Famous Hoaxes That Fooled the World for Years
- 15 Child Stars with Tragic Adult Lives
- 16 Famous Jewelry Pieces in History
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.
