30 Old Video Games in Closets That Sell Fast Online
A shoebox of old cartridges rarely looks like much until someone checks what’s actually inside. Print runs from the 1980s and 1990s were often small compared to how popular a game became later, and cardboard boxes weren’t built to survive decades of basement storage.
The games below tend to move quickly once listed, especially with original packaging intact. Here’s what’s worth pulling out before a donation run.
Super Mario Bros. for NES
Nintendo’s 1985 pack-in title sold in enormous numbers, but sealed or complete-in-box copies with an intact cardboard box are considerably rarer than loose cartridges. Early production runs used a specific hangtab box style that collectors distinguish from later reprints.
Even a common loose cartridge sells reliably online, just for far less than a boxed original.
The Legend of Zelda for NES
This 1986 release introduced the gold cartridge design that made it visually distinct from every other NES game on a shelf. Complete-in-box copies with the original styrofoam tray insert bring significantly more than a cartridge alone.
Its status as a foundational franchise title keeps demand steady even among buyers who never plan to actually play it.
Chrono Trigger for Super Nintendo
Squaresoft’s 1995 role-playing game had a comparatively modest print run in North America relative to its later reputation as one of the best-regarded games of its generation. Prices climbed steadily once retro gaming communities rediscovered it in the 2000s.
A complete copy with the original box and manual sells for a solid multiple of a loose cartridge.
EarthBound for Super Nintendo
Nintendo’s 1995 release struggled commercially in North America, partly due to marketing that leaned into self-deprecating humor rather than the game’s actual strengths. That weak initial sales performance means fewer copies exist relative to the cult following it built over the following decades.
The oversized box, included specifically to hold a bundled strategy guide, makes complete examples especially bulky and prone to damage.
Mega Man 2 for NES
Capcom’s 1988 sequel is widely regarded as the high point of the original series and consistently outsells other entries in resale markets. Box art quality varies notably between printings, and collectors specifically track which cover art matches which production run.
A complete boxed copy in strong condition moves quickly whenever it’s listed.
Pokémon Red and Blue for Game Boy
Nintendo’s 1998 North American release launched a franchise that remains commercially dominant decades later, which keeps steady demand for early physical copies. Sealed, factory-fresh copies from this original release have become especially valuable as grading services made authentication more reliable.
Even well-used cartridges without a box sell quickly given the franchise’s enormous ongoing popularity.
Metroid for NES
Nintendo’s 1986 release introduced a nonlinear exploration style that influenced an entire genre of games named after it decades later. The gold-colored cartridge, similar to the Zelda release, makes it visually distinct on a shelf.
Complete-in-box copies are notably harder to find than the cartridge-only version most people kept.
Sonic the Hedgehog for Sega Genesis
Sega’s 1989 mascot launch title sold as a pack-in with many console bundles, which paradoxically makes complete boxed standalone copies less common than the sheer sales figures might suggest. Specific early print variations in the box art and cartridge label are tracked closely by Sega collectors.
It remains one of the most consistently searched-for Genesis titles in resale markets.
Final Fantasy VII for PlayStation
Square’s 1997 release arrived as a multi-disc set, and complete copies with all discs, the manual, and the original jewel case intact are notably harder to find than a single disc alone. Its role in popularizing role-playing games with a wider Western audience has kept demand for physical copies strong for decades.
Specific early print runs with particular disc artwork variations carry an additional premium among specialists.
GoldenEye 007 for Nintendo 64
Rare’s 1997 licensed movie tie-in defied low expectations for movie-based games and became one of the best-selling and most influential titles on the console. Complete boxed copies remain reasonably available given how many units originally sold, but strong-condition examples still move quickly online.
Its lasting reputation as a genre-defining shooter keeps steady demand among collectors who grew up with the console.
Streets of Rage 2 for Sega Genesis
Sega’s 1992 sequel is frequently cited as the high point of the beat-em-up genre on the console, with a soundtrack that developed its own dedicated following separate from the game itself. Complete boxed copies in strong condition sell reliably to collectors specifically focused on Genesis-era action titles.
Its critical reputation has only grown since original release, unlike many contemporaries that faded from memory.
Super Metroid for Super Nintendo
Nintendo’s 1994 release is widely regarded as a high point of the 16-bit era, though it arrived relatively late in the console’s commercial lifespan, limiting its original print run. That late-cycle release timing is part of why complete copies command a real premium compared to earlier Super Nintendo titles.
Specialists specifically track box condition, since the cardboard used in this printing is prone to noticeable wear.
Donkey Kong Country for Super Nintendo
Rare’s 1994 release used pre-rendered computer graphics that looked strikingly advanced compared to typical 16-bit visuals at the time. It sold extremely well originally, which keeps loose cartridges common, but complete boxed copies in strong condition remain a reliable quick sale.
Its commercial success helped extend the Super Nintendo’s relevance late into its console generation.
Mother 3 Import Copies for Game Boy Advance
Nintendo released this 2006 sequel only in Japan, never officially localizing it for Western markets despite persistent fan demand over subsequent decades. Import copies purchased or shipped from Japan are the only way to own a physical release, which keeps demand notably strong among English-speaking collectors.
A community-made fan translation patch, while unofficial, has only intensified interest in owning the original cartridge.
Contra for NES
Konami’s 1988 run-and-gun title became known partly for its difficulty and partly for a cheat code that entered gaming culture well beyond the game itself. Complete boxed copies with the distinctive cover art are a consistent seller among NES collectors.
Its enduring reputation as one of the console’s defining action titles keeps demand active even among casual sellers unaware of its history.
Panzer Dragoon Saga for Sega Saturn
Sega’s 1998 role-playing game arrived late in the Saturn’s commercial life and received a notably small print run in North America as a result. That limited distribution has made it one of the more expensive complete Saturn titles in the current resale market.
A sealed or complete copy is rare enough that specialists track individual sales closely.
Ocarina of Time for Nintendo 64
Nintendo’s 1998 release is frequently cited among the most influential three-dimensional adventure games ever made, and its commercial success kept print runs relatively high. That high production volume means loose cartridges remain common, but complete gold-cartridge boxed copies still sell quickly given the title’s lasting reputation.
Specific early printing variations in the box are tracked by Nintendo 64 specialists.
Suikoden II for PlayStation
Konami’s 1999 role-playing game sold modestly in North America despite strong critical reception, leading to a comparatively small surviving population of complete copies. Its reputation grew substantially after release through word of mouth among role-playing game enthusiasts.
Complete copies with the manual and case intact now rank among the more expensive PlayStation titles in the secondary market.
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night for PlayStation
Konami’s 1997 release helped define an entire subgenre of side-scrolling action games named partly after this title’s own franchise. Original sales were modest before its reputation grew substantially over the following years.
Complete boxed copies with the original case artwork are a dependable quick sale among fans of the genre it helped popularize.
Bomberman 64 for Nintendo 64
Hudson Soft’s 1997 three-dimensional take on the long-running franchise sold reasonably well but is often overshadowed by more famous Nintendo 64 titles from the same era. Complete boxed copies remain relatively attainable compared to some rarer titles on this list, which makes it a reliable seller rather than a dramatic one.
Multiplayer-focused party games from this generation generally hold consistent resale demand.
Shenmue for Sega Dreamcast
Sega’s 2000 release was famously one of the most expensive games ever produced at the time, featuring an open world and level of detail unusual for its era. The Dreamcast’s early commercial discontinuation limited its overall install base, which keeps demand for complete copies notably strong among collectors focused on the console.
Its ambitious scope has earned it a lasting reputation among gaming historians well beyond its original commercial performance.
Kirby’s Adventure for NES
HAL Laboratory’s 1993 release arrived near the very end of the NES’s commercial lifespan, giving it one of the smaller print runs among first-party Nintendo titles for the console. Complete boxed copies are correspondingly harder to find than earlier NES releases from the same publisher.
Its late release timing is a detail collectors specifically check when evaluating a copy’s rarity.
Final Fantasy VI for Super Nintendo
Squaresoft released this 1994 title in North America under the “Final Fantasy III” numbering due to earlier entries being skipped for Western release at the time. That numbering confusion is itself a detail collectors reference when discussing the game’s history.
Complete boxed copies command a strong premium, reflecting the title’s lasting critical reputation.
Star Fox for Super Nintendo
Nintendo’s 1993 release used a specialized graphics chip built directly into the cartridge to achieve three-dimensional visuals the console couldn’t otherwise produce. That added hardware makes the cartridge itself notably heavier than a standard Super Nintendo game, a detail sellers sometimes mention to prove authenticity.
Complete boxed copies remain a consistent seller among collectors interested in the console’s more technically ambitious titles.
NBA Jam for Sega Genesis
Acclaim’s 1993 home conversion of the arcade basketball game became one of the best-selling sports titles of its console generation. Its broad original popularity keeps loose cartridges common, but complete boxed copies in strong condition still sell reliably.
Sports titles from this era generally see less collector attention than role-playing or action games, making this one a notable exception.
Earthworm Jim for Sega Genesis
Shiny Entertainment’s 1994 platformer stood out for its distinctive animation style and irreverent tone, developed by a small team compared to typical publisher-backed titles of the era. Complete boxed copies remain a dependable seller among collectors interested in unusual or creatively distinct games from the period.
Its visual style has aged in a way that keeps it recognizable even to buyers unfamiliar with the specific title.
Bushido Blade for PlayStation
Squaresoft’s 1997 fighting game departed from genre conventions by removing traditional health bars in favor of realistic single-hit combat mechanics. That unusual design approach limited its mainstream commercial appeal at the time, which now translates into a smaller surviving population of complete copies.
Fighting game specialists specifically seek this title out for its historical significance within the genre’s broader development.
Illusion of Gaia for Super Nintendo
Enix’s 1994 action role-playing game arrived relatively late in the console’s American commercial lifespan and received limited marketing support compared to bigger franchise titles. That combination has made complete boxed copies notably harder to find than the game’s quality might suggest to someone discovering it today.
Collectors specifically focused on lesser-known Super Nintendo role-playing titles treat this one as a priority find.
Vagrant Story for PlayStation
Squaresoft’s 2000 release arrived late in the PlayStation’s commercial lifespan and sold modestly despite strong critical reception at the time. Its intricate crafting and combat systems built a smaller but notably dedicated following over the years since release.
Complete copies with the original case and manual are a reliable seller among specialists focused on the publisher’s less mainstream catalog entries.
River City Ransom for NES
Technos Japan’s 1989 beat-em-up combined side-scrolling combat with role-playing elements like leveling up strength and stamina, an unusual mix for the genre at the time. It sold modestly on original release but built a dedicated following through re-releases and word of mouth over the following decades.
Complete boxed copies with the original artwork are notably scarcer than the game’s later cult status might suggest.
The Closet Nobody Thought to Check
— Photo by robtek
None of these games looked like an investment when they first came home in a paper bag from a store that probably doesn’t exist anymore. A cartridge got played through a summer, replaced by the next big release, and eventually shoved into a box that made it into a closet instead of a landfill purely by accident.
Nobody was thinking about resale value while blowing dust out of a cartridge slot in 1994.
That’s precisely why these boxes are worth opening before they’re donated or thrown away. A stack of old games that looks like clutter to one person might represent a genuinely fast sale to someone who’s been searching specifically for that title, box and all, for longer than the seller realizes.
More from Go2Tutors!
- The Romanov Crown Jewels and Their Tragic Fate
- 13 Historical Mysteries That Science Still Can’t Solve
- Famous Hoaxes That Fooled the World for Years
- 15 Child Stars with Tragic Adult Lives
- 16 Famous Jewelry Pieces in History
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.
