31 Old Books on Family Shelves That Rare Book Dealers Would Gladly Buy
Most old books are worth less than the shelf holding them. Book dealers spend their weekends explaining this to families who arrive with boxes of Reader’s Digest condensed volumes and water-stained encyclopedias.
Then someone brings in a plain-looking novel with the right words on the copyright page, and the dealer goes very quiet. First printings, original dust jackets, and tiny typos are what separate a used book from a rare one.
Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, 1997 Bloomsbury
Bloomsbury printed only 500 hardcover copies of J.K. Rowling’s first book in June 1997, and about 300 of those went to libraries. A genuine first printing names the author as Joanne Rowling on the copyright page, shows a number line running from 10 down to 1, and lists 1 wand twice in the school supply list on page 53.
Copies in good condition sell for tens of thousands of dollars, and exceptional ones have crossed six figures. Library stamps, spine labels, and heavy reading wear lower the price, though even a battered ex-library copy draws serious offers.
The first American edition from Scholastic is worth far less but still collected.
Lord of the Rings First Editions
George Allen and Unwin published J.R.R. Tolkien’s trilogy in 1954 and 1955, and first printings of all three volumes in dust jackets trade at tens of thousands of dollars as a set. The first impression of The Fellowship of the Ring had a print run of about 3,000 copies.
Each volume came with a folding map at the back, and missing maps cut the value sharply. Collectors check the title page and copyright details to confirm first impressions.
Faded spines, chipped jackets, and foxing are common flaws. A set with matching first impressions is far harder to assemble than a single volume.
The Great Gatsby With the Sick in Tired Error
Scribner published F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel in April 1925, and first printings contain a typo on page 205 that reads sick in tired instead of sick and tired. The phrase was corrected in later printings, which makes it one of the easiest first printing tests in American literature.
First printings without a jacket sell for thousands of dollars. The original dust jacket, with its painting of a face floating above a carnival, is so rare that jacketed copies reach six figures.
Faded cloth, loose hinges, and ownership inscriptions lower value, though an inscription from Fitzgerald himself changes everything.
To Kill a Mockingbird on the 1960 Lippincott Stock
J.B. Lippincott published Harper Lee’s only novel of her lifetime in July 1960, with a modest first printing of about 5,000 copies. A genuine first states First Edition on the copyright page, and the dust jacket shows a photograph of Lee taken by her friend Truman Capote on the back panel.
Jacketed first printings sell for 10,000 dollars and up, and signed copies go far beyond that. Book club editions look similar but are smaller, lack a price on the jacket flap, and carry a small blind stamp on the back board.
Faded spines, chipped jackets, and price-clipped flaps all lower value.
The Catcher in the Rye With the Salinger Photo
Little, Brown published J.D. Salinger’s novel in July 1951, and the first-state dust jacket carries a large photograph of the author on the back panel. Salinger disliked the photo and had it removed from later printings, so first printings with that jacket are the prize.
They sell for thousands to tens of thousands of dollars depending on condition. The jacket’s price of 3.00 dollars on the front flap is another point collectors check.
Faded spines, chips, and tears lower value, and a copy with a later jacket is worth far less than one with the photo.
Cat in the Hat With the 200/200 Price Code
Random House published Dr. Seuss’s The Cat in the Hat in 1957, and true first printings have a dust jacket priced at 200/200 on the front flap. Later printings changed the price, and book club editions lack it entirely.
Many copies were read to pieces by children, so clean firsts in the original jacket are rare and sell for thousands of dollars. The boards should be smooth and the spine tight.
Crayon marks, torn pages, and names written inside all lower value. Early printings without the correct jacket still bring hundreds.
Where the Wild Things Are Before the Caldecott Seal
Harper and Row published Maurice Sendak’s picture book in 1963, and it won the Caldecott Medal the following year. First printings have a dust jacket priced at 3.50 dollars and no award seal on the front, since the medal had not yet been won.
These copies sell for thousands of dollars in good condition. Later printings added the gold Caldecott seal, which dates them after 1964.
Children’s books suffer heavy wear, so clean copies with intact jackets are scarce. Tears, stains, and missing jacket pieces lower the price considerably.
Winnie-the-Pooh From Methuen in 1926
Methuen published A.A. Milne’s Winnie-the-Pooh in London in October 1926, with illustrations by E.H. Shepard. First editions in the original dust jacket sell for thousands of dollars, and signed copies reach much higher.
The deluxe editions bound in leather and the large paper limited editions signed by both Milne and Shepard are the most valuable. Collectors check the title page, the Methuen imprint, and the date.
Faded green cloth, foxed pages, and missing jackets are common. The companion volume, The House at Pooh Corner from 1928, is also collected.
Peter Rabbit in Frederick Warne Boards
Beatrix Potter privately printed 250 copies of The Tale of Peter Rabbit in 1901 after publishers rejected it. Frederick Warne then published the first trade edition in 1902, and early printings in the original boards sell for thousands of dollars.
The privately printed edition is far rarer and reaches tens of thousands. Collectors check for the correct binding, the endpapers, and the color plates.
Worn corners, faded boards, and loose plates lower value. Many later printings exist, and the details that separate the first trade printing from later ones require expert eyes.
Wonderful Wizard of Oz From George M. Hill
George M. Hill Company of Chicago published L. Frank Baum’s The Wonderful Wizard of Oz in 1900, with color illustrations by W.W. Denslow. First editions sell for tens of thousands of dollars in good condition.
Collectors check for first state points, including the text and plate details that changed during the printing run. The book was heavily read by children, so many copies are worn, stained, or missing plates.
Worn cloth, loose hinges, and damaged plates lower value. Later printings and editions from other publishers are worth much less.
Gone With the Wind Stating Published May, 1936
Macmillan published Margaret Mitchell’s novel in 1936, and first printings state Published May, 1936 on the copyright page with no later printing information. The book sold a million copies within six months, so later printings are common and worth little.
First printings in the original dust jacket sell for thousands of dollars, and signed copies reach much higher. The jacket should list the price of 3.00 dollars on the front flap.
Faded spines, chipped jackets, and heavy wear lower value. Book club editions are common and worth very little.
Joy of Cooking From Its Self-Published 1931 Run
Irma Rombauer self-published The Joy of Cooking in 1931, paying a St. Louis printing company to produce about 3,000 copies. Bobbs-Merrill picked it up for a commercial edition in 1936, and it became one of the best-selling cookbooks in American history.
The 1931 original sells for thousands of dollars. Kitchen use left most copies stained and worn, so clean examples are rare.
Grease stains, torn pages, and loose bindings lower value, and a copy with its original dust jacket is almost unheard of. The illustrations by Rombauer’s daughter, Marion Rombauer Becker, appear in the original edition.
Fannie Farmer’s 1896 Boston Cooking-School Cook Book
Little, Brown published Fannie Merritt Farmer’s Boston Cooking-School Cook Book in 1896 with a first printing of about 3,000 copies, and the publisher was cautious enough to have the author cover the printing costs. The book popularized precise level measurements in American recipes, replacing vague instructions like a lump of butter the size of an egg.
First editions sell for thousands of dollars. Like most cookbooks, copies were used hard at the stove, so clean examples are rare.
Grease spots, torn pages, and loose bindings lower the price, and the many later editions are common and worth little.
Nancy Drew’s Secret of the Old Clock From 1930
Grosset and Dunlap published The Secret of the Old Clock in 1930, the first Nancy Drew mystery, under the pen name Carolyn Keene. The ghostwriter was Mildred Wirt Benson, a journalist from Iowa who wrote many of the early books in the series.
First printings in the original dust jacket sell for thousands of dollars, and the jacket carries most of the value. Collectors check the list of titles on the back panel and inside the jacket, since the list grew as the series expanded.
The earliest copies list only the first three books. Faded spines, chipped jackets, and child-sized fingerprints lower the price.
Stephen King’s Carrie With the P6 Code
Doubleday published Stephen King’s first novel in 1974 with a first printing of about 30,000 copies. A genuine first has a small code, P6, printed in the gutter near the bottom of page 199, a printer’s mark that changed with later printings.
First editions in the original dust jacket sell for hundreds to low thousands of dollars, and signed copies go higher. The jacket should carry a price of 5.95 dollars on the front flap.
Book club editions are common and lack the code. Faded spines, chipped jackets, and heavy reading wear lower value.
Hemingway’s Sun Also Rises With the Stoppped Typo
Scribner published Ernest Hemingway’s first novel in 1926, and first printings contain a typo on page 181, where the word stopped appears with three p’s. The error was corrected in later printings.
First printings sell for thousands of dollars, and copies in the original dust jacket, which is extremely rare, reach six figures. Collectors also check for other first-state points on the title page and in the text.
Faded cloth, loose hinges, and ownership marks lower the price. The jacket, with its classical Greek figures, is the real prize.
Of Mice and Men With the Pendula Line
Covici-Friede published John Steinbeck’s novella in 1937, and the first issue has two famous points. On page 9, the text includes the phrase and only moved because the heavy hands were pendula, which was removed in later issues.
On page 88, a dot appears between the two 8s in the page number. First issues with both points sell for thousands of dollars, and jacketed copies go higher.
Collectors check both details carefully. Faded spines, chipped jackets, and heavy wear lower the price, and later issues are worth much less.
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory From Knopf in 1964
Alfred A. Knopf published Roald Dahl’s Charlie and the Chocolate Factory in the United States in 1964, before the British edition appeared in 1967. First printings in the original dust jacket sell for thousands of dollars.
The illustrations by Joseph Schindelman appear in the first edition, and the jacket should carry a price on the front flap. Children’s books suffer heavy wear, so clean copies are scarce.
Torn jackets, stained pages, and loose bindings lower the price. Later printings and book club editions are common and worth less.
Atlas Shrugged in Its 1957 First Printing
Random House published Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged in 1957, and first printings have a green dust jacket with a price of 6.95 dollars on the front flap. The novel runs over 1,100 pages, and its size made it prone to spine damage and loose bindings.
First printings in good condition sell for hundreds to thousands of dollars, and signed copies reach much higher. Collectors check the copyright page for First Printing.
Faded spines, chipped jackets, and heavy wear lower value. Book club editions look similar but are worth much less.
Catch-22 From Simon and Schuster in 1961
Simon and Schuster published Joseph Heller’s Catch-22 in 1961, and the title itself came late, since the working title used a different number that clashed with another novel due out that year. First printings in the original dust jacket, with its red and blue design and a small stylized figure, sell for hundreds to low thousands of dollars.
The front flap should carry a price of 5.95 dollars. Collectors check the copyright page for first printing information.
Faded spines, chipped jacket edges, and heavy reading wear lower value, and signed or inscribed copies bring far more.
On the Road From Viking in 1957
Viking published Jack Kerouac’s On the Road in September 1957, six years after he typed a draft on a continuous roll of taped-together paper. A glowing review in The New York Times made Kerouac famous almost overnight, and the first printing sold quickly.
First printings in the original dust jacket, priced at 3.95 dollars on the front flap, sell for several thousand dollars. Collectors check the copyright page and the black cloth binding.
The jacket’s spine fades easily, and chips along the top edge are common. Signed copies reach far higher, since Kerouac signed relatively few.
Boy Scout Handbook Original Edition of 1910
The Boy Scouts of America issued a provisional handbook in 1910, adapted largely from Robert Baden-Powell’s British manual and material by Ernest Thompson Seton, before releasing the official version in 1911. Collectors call the 1910 book the Original Edition, and genuine copies sell for hundreds to a few thousand dollars.
Many facsimile reprints were produced in later decades, so buyers check paper stock, printing details, and the publisher’s information carefully. Most copies were carried in pockets and on camping trips, so worn covers and loose pages are common.
Clean copies with tight bindings are scarce.
Little House in the Big Woods From 1932
Harper and Brothers published Laura Ingalls Wilder’s first book in 1932, when the author was 65 years old. The first edition carried illustrations by Helen Sewell, and the familiar Garth Williams drawings arrived with the revised editions of 1953.
First printings in the original dust jacket sell for thousands of dollars, and copies without a jacket bring hundreds. Collectors check the copyright page and the illustrations to confirm a first.
Children’s books suffer heavy wear, so torn jackets, loose hinges, and crayon marks are common. A clean jacketed copy is a real find for a Wilder collector.
Anne of Green Gables From L.C. Page in 1908
L.C. Page and Company of Boston published Lucy Maud Montgomery’s first novel in 1908, and the original cover shows a woman in profile rather than a red-haired girl, a choice readers have puzzled over ever since. Montgomery later spent years in legal disputes with the publisher over royalties.
First impressions sell for tens of thousands of dollars, and later printings from the same year bring less. Collectors check the copyright page and the cover label carefully.
Worn cloth, faded covers, and loose bindings lower the price. Early Canadian and British editions are also collected.
Tarzan of the Apes From A.C. McClurg in 1914
A.C. McClurg of Chicago published Edgar Rice Burroughs’s Tarzan of the Apes in 1914, two years after the story first ran in a pulp magazine. The first printing ran to about 5,000 copies, and collectors check the printer’s imprint on the copyright page to confirm it.
Copies without a dust jacket sell for thousands of dollars, while jacketed copies are so rare that they reach six figures. Worn cloth, faded spines, and loose hinges are common, since the book was read hard by a generation of boys.
Later printings from the same publisher are much more common and worth less.
Dune From an Auto Repair Manual Publisher
Frank Herbert’s Dune was rejected by many publishers before Chilton Books, a company known for its auto repair manuals, published it in 1965. The first printing was only a few thousand copies, and the book went on to win the first Nebula Award for best novel.
First printings in the original dust jacket, priced at 5.95 dollars, sell for thousands of dollars and far more in top condition. Book club editions are common and lack the price.
Faded spines, chipped jackets, and heavy wear lower value. Signed first printings are among the most sought-after science fiction books.
Watership Down From Rex Collings
Richard Adams wrote Watership Down from stories he told his daughters, and the manuscript was rejected by several publishers before Rex Collings, a small London firm, took it on in 1972. The first printing was only about 2,500 copies, and the book went on to sell millions.
First printings in the original dust jacket sell for thousands of dollars. Collectors check the map on the endpapers and the copyright page.
Faded spines, chipped jackets, and loose bindings lower value. The first American edition from Macmillan in 1974 is more common and worth much less.
Slaughterhouse-Five From 1969
Delacorte Press published Kurt Vonnegut’s Slaughterhouse-Five in 1969 under the Seymour Lawrence imprint, drawing on his experience as a prisoner of war during the firebombing of Dresden. First printings in the original dust jacket sell for hundreds to thousands of dollars, and signed copies bring more.
The jacket should carry a price of 5.95 dollars on the front flap. Collectors check the copyright page for first printing information.
Faded spines, chipped jackets, and heavy wear lower value. Book club editions are common and look similar but lack the price and carry a blind stamp.
A Game of Thrones From 1996
Bantam Spectra published George R.R. Martin’s A Game of Thrones in the United States in 1996, and HarperCollins published it in the UK the same year under its Voyager imprint. The first printings were modest, since the series had not yet become a phenomenon.
First printings in the original dust jacket sell for hundreds to low thousands of dollars, and signed copies go higher. Collectors check the number line on the copyright page.
Faded spines, chipped jackets, and heavy reading wear lower value. The television adaptation that began in 2011 pushed prices up sharply.
Goodnight Moon From 1947
Margaret Wise Brown’s Goodnight Moon came out from Harper in 1947, with illustrations by Clement Hurd. The book sold slowly at first, and the influential New York Public Library did not stock it for decades because its children’s librarian disliked it.
First printings in the original dust jacket sell for thousands of dollars. The jacket should carry the original price on the front flap.
Children’s books suffer heavy wear, and torn pages, stains, and crayon marks are common. Clean first printings with intact jackets are among the most sought-after American picture books.
Charlotte’s Web From 1952
E.B. White’s Charlotte’s Web arrived from Harper in 1952, with illustrations by Garth Williams, and it grew out of White’s own barn in Maine. First printings in the original dust jacket sell for thousands of dollars, and signed copies bring more.
Collectors check the copyright page and the jacket details, including the price on the front flap. Children’s books suffer heavy wear, and torn jackets, stained pages, and loose bindings are common.
Later printings are far more common and worth much less. A clean first with an intact jacket is a significant find for collectors of American children’s literature.
Copyright Pages Tell the Story
Most old books are worth less than the paper they are printed on, and dealers spend their days explaining that to hopeful families. The valuable ones hide in plain sight, often looking no different from the reprints beside them.
A typo, a price on a jacket flap, or a single line on the copyright page makes all the difference. Dust jackets were thrown away by the millions, and the survivors now carry most of the value.
The books that last are usually the ones nobody read, or the ones read carefully by someone who treated the jacket like part of the book. That care, long forgotten, is what dealers pay for.
More from Go2Tutors!
- The Romanov Crown Jewels and Their Tragic Fate
- 13 Historical Mysteries That Science Still Can’t Solve
- Famous Hoaxes That Fooled the World for Years
- 15 Child Stars with Tragic Adult Lives
- 16 Famous Jewelry Pieces in History
Like Go2Tutors’s content? Follow us on MSN.
